MyHeart

  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Authors
  • Resources
    • MitraClip University
      • Advanced Steering
    • POTS Center
    • Heart Healthy Nutrition
    • MyHeart Videos
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising
Home / Lactic Acid – Overview / Lactic Acid – Misconceptions and Myths

Lactic Acid – Misconceptions and Myths

Lactic Acid Guide

Lactic Acid – An Overview

What Is Lactic Acid?

Why Is Lactic Acid Produced?

Where is Lactic Acid Produced?

How is Lactic Acid Produced?

What Happens to Lactic Acid?

The Difference Between Lactic Acid and Lactate

So What Does Make the Cells Acidic?

Measuring Lactic Acid Levels

Lactic Acid – The Truth

Lactic Acid – Misconceptions and Myths

Lactic Acid – Commercial Applications

Lactate Threshold

 

Lactic Acid – Misconceptions and Myths

If you ask most people what limits them from exercising at high intensities they will often reply saying “the burn” in the muscles being used and if you ask them what causes this burn they reply “lactic acid”. For near a century now it has been thought and widely taught that lactic acid produced by the muscles through anaerobic metabolism is responsible for this burn and resultant muscle fatigue, but in reality this simply isn’t true and there has actually never been any scientific evidence to suggest this is the case!

“even though we now clearly know otherwise”

As with many scientific discoveries, especially in years past, initial findings were later modified or disproven and it can take decades of changing beliefs before thoughts become more concrete, and this can definitely be said for lactic acid. The interesting thing in this case however is that even though we now clearly know otherwise, the myth is still widely believed to be reality and still referred to as gospel in the scientific community!

So where did it start?

To understand where the myth originated, we must go back to the origins and the initial works on the subject by Otto Meyerhoff and Archibald V. Hill who were both actually awarded the Nobel Prize for their work on carbohydrate metabolism in skeletal muscle.

Their work was carried out at a time when scientific thinking was that in order for muscle contraction to occur, oxygen was necessary to produce the energy required. The first important discovery they made was that in the absence of oxygen, glycolysis could occur and that lactic acid was a product of this reaction. Through further calculations they then determined that this reaction yielded large amounts of energy in a short time and could fuel rapid and powerful muscle contractions.

“in the absence of oxygen large amounts of energy could be produced”

What they also realized was that during intense muscle contractions the energy required by the muscles was up to 8 times more than could possibly be provided by oxygen alone at maximum consumption rates (Hill 1924).

This led them to the conclusion that large amounts of energy could be provided in the absence of oxygen by the conversion of glucose to lactic acid via glycolysis. Up to this point they were certainly correct in their thoughts but they then did something that is very dangerous in science and came to a conclusion based on logical thought. They concluded by simple ‘cause and effect’ that anaerobic (without oxygen) metabolism led to the production of lactic acid which was responsible for the acidosis in the cell and the resultant muscle fatigue.

“the thought that lactate production leads to acidosis is simply not true and should be removed from all future teaching”

Since this assumption was made there has been no hard evidence to support the case apart from simple correlations, which carry very little if any weight at all unless elaborated on by further investigations. The belief that the lactic acid produced releases a proton (H+) resulting in an acidosis is simply not true and must be removed from future teaching.

References

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Connect with:
Facebook Google Twitter
If you need immediate medical attention, please call 911. These comments are not guaranteed to be read in a timely manner and should not be used to seek immediate medical advice.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts

  • Arts in Medicine with Kimberly Kirklin at UAB and Dr Rachel Easterwood in New York
  • THE CHRONIC LEAKY MITRAL VALVE
  • Leaky Mitral Valve
  • THE CHRONIC LEAKY AORTIC VALVE
  • Leaky Aortic Valve

Categories

  • Aortic disease (7)
  • Featured Articles (64)
  • General Health (38)
    • Complementary Medicine (1)
  • Heart Disease (176)
    • Cardiac Arrhythmias (17)
    • Coronary Artery Disease (51)
    • Heart Failure and Cardiomyopathies (29)
    • Heart Valves (46)
  • Heart Health (111)
    • Diet & Nutrition (36)
    • Exercise (34)
    • Risk & Prevention (54)
  • Medical News (9)
  • Podcast (64)
  • Tests & Investigations (28)
  • Uncategorized (3)
  • Vascular Disease (27)
    • Hypertension (High Blood Pressure) (14)
RECENT POSTS
  • Arts in Medicine with Kimberly Kirklin at UAB and Dr Rachel Easterwood in New York
  • THE CHRONIC LEAKY MITRAL VALVE
  • Leaky Mitral Valve
  • THE CHRONIC LEAKY AORTIC VALVE
  • Leaky Aortic Valve
FOLLOW US
ABOUT MY HEART

MyHeart is a group of physicians dedicated to empowering patients to take control of their health. Read by over a million people every year, MyHeart is quickly becoming a “go to” resource for patients across the world.

POPULAR TOPICS ON MYHEART
  • POTS Syndrome Center
  • Earlobe Crease & Heart Disease
  • Atrial Fibrillation with RVR
  • STEMI
  • MitraClip
  • Mitral Regurgitation
NAVIGATION
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Our Team
    • Authors
  • Resources
    • MitraClip University
      • Advanced Steering
    • POTS Center
    • Heart Healthy Nutrition
    • MyHeart Videos
  • Articles
  • Podcasts
  • Contact Us
  • Advertising

Privacy Policy. Terms of Use.
© 2023 MyHeart. All rights reserved.
MyHeart is not a substitute for advice from a doctor. Read our medical disclaimer. Sitemap.